Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Man avoids Portuguese jail for beating of ex-wife with nail-spiked club because her infidelity brought him 'dishonour'

Ruling blames 'disloyalty and sexual immorality' of the victim for the attack

Tom Embury-Dennis
Friday 27 October 2017 12:29 BST
Comments
Porto's Palace of Justice
Porto's Palace of Justice (Google Maps)

A man who beat his ex-wife with a nail-spiked club has been spared jail by a Portuguese court because her infidelity brought “dishonour” on him.

After teaming up with the woman's former lover who restrained her, he hit her repeatedly with the home made weapon, court documents showed.

She was left head injuries that needed five stitches after the June 2015 attack, according to CNN which originally reported the story.

Her husband was originally given a 15 month suspended sentence and a fine.

But when this was challenged, the appeals court in Porto refused to impose a stiffer sentence on the man.

Citing the Bible and the Portuguese Penal Code of 1886, which allows little more than symbolic punishment for domestic violence, the ruling, written by Judge Joaquim Neto de Moura and co-signed by Maria Luisa Abrantes said that the woman's adultery was "a very serious attack on the honour and dignity of the man."

Domestic violence victim shares video of moment she was thrown down stairs by boyfriend

It added: "It was the disloyalty and the sexual immorality of the plaintiff that made (the defendant) fall into a profound depression, and it was in this depressive state and clouded by the revolt that carried out the act of aggression, as was well considered in the judgement under appeal."

"This case is far from having the seriousness that, generally, is presented in cases of mistreatment in the context of domestic violence. On the other hand, the conduct of the defendant took place in a context of adultery practised by the plaintiff."

The judges defended the ruling by citing a passage in the Bible that states: “The adulterous woman must be punished by death”.

The case has sparked outrage in Portugal and demonstrations against it are reportedly being planned in Porto and Lisbon.

Rights group Amnesty International also called the verdict a “reflection of a culture and justice than promotes misogyny”.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in